Skip to main content
Blog What California’s Rent Reporting Law Teaches Us About Implementing Policies with No Budget
Daniel Teles, Amanda Hermans, Brett Theodos
Display Date

Modern apartment building on a city street corner.

Amid the affordability crisis, policymakers are increasingly focused on legislation that can improve financial stability and opportunity for renters. But what makes a policy effective? We analyzed the implementation and impact of California’s first-of-its-kind statewide rent reporting legislation, Senate Bill 1157, and identified key trade-offs policymakers should consider when designing similar legislation.

In 2020, California passed a statewide mandate requiring affordable housing providers to provide rent reporting options to tenants. Lawmakers were motivated by evidence that rent reporting—the practice of reporting rental payments to major credit bureaus—is a promising credit-building tool that can improve renters’ credit standing. The bill’s sponsors hoped to move beyond pilot programs already underway in other cities and states.

The bill’s drafters included a coalition of staffers from California Senator Steven Bradford’s office and advocacy organizations Credit Builders’ Alliance (CBA), Prosperity Now, and Mission Asset Fund. They originally intended to apply the law to all housing but quickly amended it to only affordable housing properties with at least 16 units to address differences between affordable and market-rate housing and avoid burdening small landlords. The law was also set to sunset after five years because the drafters felt a permanent mandate would not pass. Crucially, the law carried no state costs and provided no budget for outreach, education, or enforcement, allowing it to skip the appropriations process and pass more easily.

We interviewed more than a dozen stakeholders involved in drafting or implementing S.B. 1157, including legislative staff, industry stakeholders, housing providers, and third-party rent reporting service providers. We also analyzed data on the rate of rent reporting in properties covered by the mandate and comparable properties that were not. 

We found that despite limited outreach and no compliance enforcement, many affordable housing providers offered rent reporting to tenants. But tenant participation remained modest, suggesting that more education about the potential benefits of rent reporting may be needed for tenants.

Without funding for outreach, implementation relies on third parties

Without funding for outreach or enforcement, lawmakers initially relied on advocacy groups to inform housing providers about the new law. These groups, including some who had been involved in the legislation’s drafting, focused on informing large associations of housing providers and property managers to spread, but without a budget or state resources, outreach remained limited.

Most of the outreach and education to housing providers came from third-party rent reporting companies. (Notable firms in this space include Esusu, Piñata, IDIQ, Bilt, Self, and Boom, among others.) Though these groups were not actively engaged in drafting the bill, many saw an opportunity to market their compliant services. The companies we spoke with told us that they were many housing providers’ first exposure to the legislation.

Most compliant affordable housing providers generally supported rent reporting in principle, though some had concerns around the effort required to launch a program. Many saw rent reporting as a tool for tenants that aligned well with their mission-oriented services.

At the same time, rent reporting companies helped address some implementation challenges, including converting rental data into formats accepted by the three major credit bureaus and integrating systems with existing property management data platforms.

Education and outreach are needed for both housing providers and tenants

Even when housing providers learned about the law and offered rent reporting, efforts to educate tenants remained minimal. Housing providers were required to inform tenants of rent reporting services at lease signing and annually thereafter, but there were no requirements to include educational information about the benefits of credit building and how rent reporting works.

As a result, tenant participation remained low. Among housing providers who were tracking it, we heard anecdotally that between 1 and 3 percent of residents had enrolled. This is borne out in the data. Between July 2020 and July 2024, the share of credit-visible renters in affordable housing properties with open rent trades rose from 1.1 percent to 4.8 percent. Living in affordable housing in California increased the likelihood of participation in rent reporting by 2.4 percentage points relative to California renters in market-rate housing by 2024. However, when we compare the experience of renters in affordable housing in California with peers in affordable housing in other states, California’s law increased the likelihood of participation by only half a percentage point.

Many housing providers attributed low participation to distrust in government or financial service providers. One interviewee told us many of their tenants did not have bank accounts and were unlikely to be interested in credit building. We also heard that there was a general lack of familiarity with credit scores and their value among tenants, which played a role in suppressing uptake. Some providers reported tenants’ concern about what would happen to their credit scores if they did have late payments, even though most providers we spoke with were doing positive-only reporting (or reporting positive payments, not missed payments). The legislation’s opt-in enrollment requirement also likely lowered participation.

Without an enforcement mechanism, compliance can be good but not perfect

The law did not have perfect compliance. Some affordable housing providers we spoke with were unaware of S.B. 1157 altogether. Others were aware of a new law but knew few details. And others still overlooked or deprioritized rent reporting requirements because of more urgent COVID-19-related policies, such as eviction moratoriums and rental relief programs.

But for a law with no outreach budget or enforcement mechanisms, achieving participation of most affordable housing providers shows significant progress.

Mandates create opportunities for tenant protections

Structuring S.B. 1157 as a mandate instead of a pilot allowed the California legislature to establish consumer protections in a rapidly growing industry.

For example, the law allowed housing providers to pass certain rent reporting costs on to tenants but capped the fee at $10 per month. Similarly, the law required providers to offer a paper enrollment option to account for renters who may not have email access (though this requirement was dropped in later amendments) and required a waiting period between notification of services and enrollment to reduce risk of coercive practices.

S.B. 1157 also required an opt-in design. Though opt-out may have been more popular with housing providers for ease and uptake (for example, it’s easier to enroll everyone at once and manage a few dropouts, rather than managing one enrollee at a time), lawmakers insisted on this specification to comply with their understanding of the federal Privacy Act of 1974 and allowable uses of data from renters living in federal subsidized housing. This may have prevented some housing providers from running afoul of federal legal requirements.

Looking forward

Although rent reporting is growing nationally, participation is still relatively rare. We found that the share of renter households participating in rent reporting nationally grew from about 2 percent to nearly 7 percent between 2020 and 2024. 

For states and localities considering rent reporting policies, California provides useful lessons for implementation and impact. Other places may decide that California’s example could support an even bolder approach. In fact, California itself has already built on S.B. 1157—in 2024, it passed Senate Bill 924 and Assembly Bill 2747, which extended and expanded S.B. 1157, removing its sunset date and applying similar requirements to all market-rate housing. This year, Maryland adopted its own rent reporting mandate, pairing a positive-only rent reporting requirement for landlords with six or more units with protections against credit-score-based screening of applicants in rental assistance programs.

California’s experience underscores the importance of weighing the political, practical, and fiscal trade-offs when deliberating the best strategies for increasing access to rent reporting options.

This research was funded by Kaiser Permanente via a grant to Credit Builders Alliance. We are grateful to them and to all our funders, who make it possible for Urban to advance its mission. The views expressed are those of the authors and should not be attributed to the Urban Institute, its trustees, or its funders. Funders do not determine research findings or the insights and recommendations of our experts. More information on our funding principles is available here.

Tags Housing Access and Stability